The real difference between tank and tankless
A tank stores a set volume of hot water, heated and ready to draw at any time. A tankless unit heats water as it flows through, on demand, so it doesn't run out the way a tank can, but it also can't draw ahead on a large stored volume the way a full tank can. Which one fits your house comes down to gas supply, venting, how the household uses hot water at the same time, and how much space you have to work with.
Gas line sizing
A tankless unit's burner has to heat water fast enough to keep up with the flow going through it, which generally asks more of the gas supply than a tank's burner does. In an older Toronto house, the existing gas line may be sized for a smaller total load, in which case fitting a tankless unit means upsizing that line. We check the gas line size and pressure at the meter before recommending tankless.
Venting
A tankless unit vents through its own dedicated plastic pipe to the outside, similar to a high-efficiency furnace, and needs a clear spot on an exterior wall for the intake and exhaust. It doesn't rely on a chimney the way an older tank might, which can help if the chimney is already carrying a furnace and getting crowded, but it does mean planning a new penetration through the wall. Getting that venting route wrong isn't only a comfort issue, it's how combustion exhaust can end up somewhere other than outside, which is why the route gets checked as part of the quote, not assumed.
Simultaneous draw
The number that matters for a tankless unit is how many fixtures it can serve heating water at the same time, not how many litres it can store. A shower and a dishwasher running together, or two showers at once, ask more of a tankless unit than either alone, and a unit sized for one bathroom can fall behind when the house asks for more than that. We ask what runs together in your house, morning routine included, before sizing a tankless unit.
A tank that runs out has to reheat the full volume before it can deliver hot water at temperature again, so back-to-back showers close together can outpace it even if the household's total daily use is modest. A tankless unit doesn't have a recovery period in the same sense, since it heats continuously as water flows, but its limit is flow rate rather than a running-out point. Knowing which limit actually matters for your household, running out of stored volume or hitting a flow-rate ceiling, is part of what decides which type fits.
Cold groundwater cuts into winter flow
Incoming water is colder in January than in August, and a tankless unit has to raise its temperature further for the same flow rate, which reduces how much hot water it can deliver at once. A tankless unit that comfortably runs two showers in summer can fall short doing the same thing in the coldest months. We size for winter conditions, not the mild months, so the unit doesn't come up short exactly when you need it most.
A tank delivers water at a fairly steady temperature once it's up to temperature, since it's drawing from a stored, already-heated volume. A tankless unit heats water as it flows, so a sudden change in flow rate elsewhere in the house, someone flushing a toilet or starting the dishwasher, can cause a brief temperature swing at the shower until the unit adjusts. A well-sized tankless system handles this better than an undersized one, which is another reason sizing for simultaneous use matters.
Descaling and maintenance
Minerals in the water settle as scale inside a tankless heat exchanger over time, which shows up as error codes and unexpected shutdowns rather than the slower popping and rumbling a scaling tank makes. Regular descaling keeps a tankless unit's heat exchanger clear, and how often that's needed depends on how hard the water is. A tank needs its own periodic flushing to clear sediment, plus a check of the anode rod: different maintenance, not none.
Space
A tankless unit mounts on the wall and takes up a fraction of the floor space a tank does, which matters in a small mechanical room, a condo's utility closet, or a basement where the space is wanted for something else. A tank needs a clear footprint on the floor and enough clearance around it for service and, on a chimney-vented tank, a straight run up.
In a condo or townhouse utility closet, the smaller footprint of a tankless unit can be the deciding factor on its own, independent of the gas line or venting questions above, simply because there isn't room for a standard tank and its clearances.
Which one fits your house
There isn't a universal right answer between tank and tankless. It comes down to your gas line, your venting options, how many fixtures run hot water at once, and how much space you have. We check the gas supply, the venting, and how the household uses hot water, and quote tank and tankless side by side when both genuinely fit. Request a water heater visit and we'll walk you through both options for your house. If your furnace is also due, see furnace replacement cost in Toronto for how the venting question overlaps between the two.