Heating guide

Repair or replace your furnace: how to decide

Most furnace problems end with a repair. Some shouldn't. Here is how we decide which side of the line your furnace is on, and what you can check yourself before you call.

Toronto Mechanical Services · Updated September 2026

Furnace not heating or something else wrong? Call and tell us what it is doing.

Call (647) 674-2387

The short version

Most gas furnaces run 15 to 20 years with regular maintenance. Age is where we start, and the repair history and the condition of the heat exchanger decide it.

Repair usually makes sense when the furnace is under 15 years old, this is its first real repair, the heat exchanger is intact, and the failed part is a sensor, igniter, motor, or board.

Replacement usually makes sense when the furnace is 15 or older and losing efficiency, it has needed two or more repairs in the last two winters, the heat exchanger is cracked, or the gas bills keep climbing even after maintenance.

A lot of furnaces sit between those two lists. That is where a proper diagnosis matters, and where we give you a written recommendation after the visit.

Parts that usually get repaired

Most no-heat calls come down to one worn part. These are the common ones:

  • Igniter. It lights the burners. Hot surface igniters wear out and crack with age. The usual sign is a furnace that tries to start and never lights.
  • Flame sensor. It confirms the burners are lit. When it gets dirty, the furnace lights and then shuts off after a few seconds. A cleaning often fixes it.
  • Inducer motor. It pulls combustion gases through the furnace and out the vent before the burners light. A worn one gets noisy, and when it stops, the furnace won't start.
  • Pressure switch. It confirms the inducer has the vent drawing properly. A failed switch stops the furnace, and so does a blocked vent or condensate line that trips it.
  • Blower motor. It moves air through the ducts. A failing one squeals, hums, or pushes weak air, and it can make the furnace overheat and shut itself off.
  • Control board. It runs the start-up sequence and the safety checks. Boards fail with age, and the blinking light on the board usually tells us where to look.

Warning signs a furnace is near the end

One of these on its own doesn't mean replacement. Two or three together, on a furnace past 15, usually does.

  • Repairs have become a yearly event.
  • The gas bill went up with no change in how you use the house.
  • Rooms that used to be comfortable now run cold.
  • The burner flame is yellow or flickers instead of a steady blue.
  • Banging, rattling, or squealing on start-up that keeps coming back after repairs.
  • The furnace short-cycles even with a clean filter and open vents.

Cracked heat exchangers and carbon monoxide

The heat exchanger keeps the burner's exhaust separate from the air your furnace blows through the house. Metal heats and cools thousands of times over a furnace's life, and eventually it can crack. A crack can let combustion gases, including carbon monoxide, into the air you breathe. That makes it a safety problem, and it is the one finding that moves a furnace straight to the replacement side.

Keep working carbon monoxide alarms near every sleeping area, and test them. If a CO alarm goes off, get everyone out of the house and call 911 from outside. Don't go back in to check the furnace.

If we find a cracked heat exchanger on a visit, we shut the furnace off and show you what we found. Not every crack is visible from the outside of the furnace, which is why we look at it directly where we can and check how the flame and combustion behave.

What happens on a diagnostic visit

We test before we replace. Swapping parts until the furnace starts is expensive for you and tells nobody what actually failed. On a furnace repair visit we:

  • Ask what the furnace has been doing, and when.
  • Check the thermostat, the power, and the filter first.
  • Run the furnace through a start-up cycle and watch where it stops.
  • Test the suspect part before ordering anything.
  • Check gas pressure, combustion air, and venting. We do this on every furnace call.
  • Look at the heat exchanger and the burners.

Weighing the repair against the furnace

Once we know what failed, the question is whether the fix is worth it on this furnace. An igniter on a ten-year-old furnace is an easy yes. A blower motor on a furnace that is 18 and had a board replaced last winter is a harder call. The repair may get you through this season, and the next part may fail next season.

We give you the repair price and our recommendation in writing, and you decide. If you want to fix it now and plan a replacement for spring, that is a reasonable plan, and we will tell you if we think the furnace can't safely get there.

If you replace, ask about a heat pump

A furnace replacement is the natural time to look at a heat pump. A cold-climate heat pump heats and cools, and a dual-fuel setup keeps a gas furnace as backup for the coldest weeks. It makes the most sense when the central AC is also getting old. Our page on cold-climate heat pumps has the details.

Standard gas furnaces are not covered by Ontario rebates. Ontario's Home Renovation Savings program currently covers qualifying heat pumps. Amounts change, and the homeowner claims it through a contractor registered with the program. Ask and we will tell you what applies to your house.

If replacement is where you land, our guide on what sets furnace replacement cost in Toronto explains what goes into the quote.

What to check before you call

A few no-heat calls are fixed before we get there. It is worth a few minutes to check:

  • The thermostat is set to heat, set above room temperature, and has fresh batteries if it uses them.
  • The furnace switch near the unit, which looks like a light switch, is on, and the breaker hasn't tripped.
  • The filter isn't clogged. A dirty filter can make a furnace overheat and shut itself off.
  • Supply vents and return grilles are open and not blocked by furniture.
  • On a high-efficiency furnace, the two plastic pipes outside aren't buried in snow or ice.

Filters and air quality

Filters need regular changes, and a clogged one is behind a lot of short-cycling and overheating calls. If your house is dusty, dry in winter, or stuffy, the fix may be on the air side more than the furnace itself. See whole-home filtration and humidity control for what can be added to an existing furnace.

If you smell gas, don't touch switches or the thermostat. Leave the house and call your gas utility's emergency line or 911 from outside. For everything else, book a furnace diagnostic and we will tell you where your furnace stands.

Questions

Is it worth repairing a 20-year-old furnace?

Sometimes, for a single inexpensive part that gets you through the winter while you plan a replacement. If it has needed two or more repairs recently, or the heat exchanger is cracked, it isn't.

Can a cracked heat exchanger be repaired?

We treat it as a replacement conversation. On an older furnace, replacing only the heat exchanger is rarely practical, and it isn't safe to keep running the furnace with a crack.

Why does my furnace light and then shut off?

A dirty flame sensor is the most common reason. A pressure switch problem or a blocked vent or condensate line can cause the same thing. We test to find which one it is.

Will you tell me if a repair isn't worth doing?

Yes. After the diagnosis we give you the repair price and our recommendation in writing. The decision is yours.

My furnace is old but works fine. Should I replace it now?

Not just because of age. Keep up the yearly maintenance and watch the repair history and gas bills. Planning ahead does help, so a failure in January doesn't force a rushed decision.

The services

More guides

Get a written quote for furnaces

Name and phone are required.

Your service request

We’ll use your details to respond to your request. Privacy policy

  1. We call you back

    At the number you gave us, to ask what the equipment is doing.

  2. We book a window

    A day and time that works. Scheduled visits outside the regular route.

  3. Written quote before work

    You see the number before anything is replaced. Nothing starts until you say so.

CallRequest service